The Impact of News

20 January 2025 By PDSNET

Old Wall Street wisdom says the following concerning news which comes out about individual listed companies:

  1. Good news which is expected - causes the share price to drop.
  2. Good news which is unexpected - causes the share price to rise.
  3. Bad news which is expected - causes the share price to rise.
  4. Bad news which is unexpected - causes the share price to drop.

To understand this, you need to first understand the concept of discounting. Discounting is probably the single most important word in the share market. It refers to the fact that investors will consider the future expected profitability of a company when deciding to buy or sell its shares. If the company is expected to be profitable then the share will go up and vice versa. If you are unclear on the concept of discounting, you should re-read module seven of the lecture notes.

But, of course, news is not disseminated to everyone at the same time – and then investors also respond to news in different ways. Because of this, news can be fully discounted, over-discounted, partially discounted, or not discounted at all into the share’s price.

Thus, when a company is about to produce results which are expected to be particularly good, that good news is usually over-discounted into the share’s price. Then, when the results actually come out, reality sets in and the share price tends to drop – sometimes quite sharply.

Take the recent example of Karoo (KRO). Based on its results for the six months to the 31st of August 2024 investors were very bullish and pushed the share price up to R925, on the 9th of January this year. This was on the expectation that the results for the third quarter would also be very good. Then, when those results were published on the 15th of January 2025, despite the fact that they were good, the share price dropped sharply to R855. Consider the chart:

Karoo (KRO): 14th of November 2024 - 17th of January 2025. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

The rules given above refer to the "unsystematic" news which affects a single share. There is also "systematic" news which impacts the market as a whole. With systematic news, the news itself is less important than how the market responds to it.

For example, the unexpectedly high US jobs number for December 2024, published on the 10th of January 2025, caused investors to take the S&P500 index down 1,54% in a single day, based on the expectation that interest rates would, as a result, be reduced more slowly. The jobs number itself showed that the economy was booming, but the immediate investor response was based purely on their concern over the speed with which interest rates would decline.

A few days later, on Wednesday last week, the US core inflation figure was published. It came in at a slightly better-than-expected 3,2% - and investors responded very enthusiastically, pushing the S&P up 1,8% in a single day, the 15th of January 2025.

After the strong 24% run-up in the S&P during 2024, investors are concerned that the market has gone up too far too fast and is now ripe for a downward trend. This means that they tend to over-react sometimes to potentially negative information – like the jobs number. We tweeted that this was probably the case on the 13th of January 2025, when we drew attention to the fact that the downward movement had been excessive. We said that we were expecting the S&P to rally as a result – which it now has done.

This was based on the understanding that the underlying sentiment in the market remained strongly bullish - and that found expression when the mildly better core inflation figure was published a few days later and resulted in a powerful relief rally.

The simple fact is that this bull trend is not over – or even nearly over. The direction of the trend is predominantly bullish. Investors are excited about the potential profitability of new technologies like AI and human robotics. But as the market goes higher, and especially when it moves into previously uncharted territory, they naturally become more nervous. It is particularly important to develop a feel for investor sentiment in order to gauge the influence of systematic factors on the market.


DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.



Share this article:

PDSNET ARTICLES

Growth by Acquisition

Hudaco (HDC) is a master of growing by acquiring smaller businesses in similar fields of activity or businesses, which then complement its existing suite of businesses. It has been making these bolt-on acquisitions for many years and has developed great expertise at selecting and evaluating appropriate targets.

These bolt-on acquisitions are mostly small

Karoo

In April 2018 – nearly seven years ago – we wrote an article about Cartrack. At the time we suggested that it was the ideal investment for private investors because it was a service company with debit order income and almost no working capital that was growing rapidly both locally and internationally.

Tweets

Over the Festive Season, we have been communicating with you via our tweets on “X”. The chart below shows the timing of our individual tweets and what subsequently happened to the S&P500 index.
 

 

Winners in 2024

2024 was always going to be a very good year for the share market. The year began with the S&P500 at 4742.83 (2/1/24) and it reached an all-time record high of 6090.27 (6/12/24) – a gain of 28,4% excluding dividends.

On the 25th of January 2024 we made the following prediction on Twitter (X):

Pan African Update

Pan African (PAN) is undoubtedly one of our best picks for this year. The share price has doubled in less than 12 months from when we added it to the Winning Shares List (WSL) at the end of January at 430c to last Friday’s close at 861c. Consider the chart:

Mr Price Interims

Almost 6 months ago, on 17th June 2024, we wrote an article about Mr Price (MRP) in which we examined their results for the year to 30th March 2024. These results had been published on the Stock Exchange News Service (SENS) a few days earlier on 13th March 2024 and they were very impressive.

Altron

Allied Electronics better known as Altron, is South Africa’s oldest technology company listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE). Since 1965 it has been providing IT solutions to the economy in various forms. Its customers include more than half of the top 100 companies listed on the JSE. It processes more than 100 million healthcare transactions every year,

Lewis Revisited

Working capital is always a key consideration when looking at a share, because it shows the quality of the company’s management. In simple terms, working capital is the cash tied up in the running of the business and it is calculated as:

Debtors + Cash – Creditors

Obviously,

Trump

I am a stock market analyst, not a political analyst, and I have to admit that I got the recent election in America devastatingly and horribly wrong. I honestly believed that the vast majority of Americans would never vote for Trump. My perception was that were just too many negatives – his proven and almost compulsive dishonesty, his life history of overt sexual perversion, his unashamed

The Great Bull Market

In recent months I have read a number of articles which suggest that the bull trend which is currently in progress on Wall Street began just over two years ago on 12th October 2022, starting from the S&P500 index’s low point of 3577.03 on that date. The technicians who make this assertion suggest that therefore the bull market is still at an early