Silver on the move?

26 July 2020 By PDSNET

One of our clients, Mr. Koot Jordaan, drew our attention to the fact that the rand price of silver, which has been underperforming gold since 2011, may be making an upside breakout.

Mr. Jordaan suggested that silver in both rands and US dollars had been moving in an extended sideways pattern. Consider the charts:

Silver in US dollars

Silver price in US dollars: February 2014 to 26 July 2020. Chart by ShareFriend Pro

(We regard the downward break in March 2020 in the US dollar chart as an aberration.)

Silver in rands

Silver price in South African rands: January 2011 to 26 July 2020. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

You can see here that silver has been moving sideways in US dollars since September 2014 and in rands since 2011. Both charts also show an upside breakout in the last week or so.

Sideways markets like this are periods of consolidation. The price is “backing and filling” while it waits for new direction. The longer the sideways pattern continues, the further up the price will go once there is a clear upside breakout. That is the basis for the horizontal count method of point and figure (P&F) charting.

If you are unsure about horizontal counts in P&F refer to our article No. 49 “Upside Target” published in December 2016. https://www.pdsnet.co.za/index.php/upside-target/ We used a P&F horizontal count to predict that the S&P500 index, then trading for about 2050, would rise to 3027 – a target which it has subsequently far exceeded.

Using Metastock, we tried various box sizes to find an unbroken horizontal count. The following charts show our results:

Silver in US dollars

Silver price in US dollars: P&F Chart. Chart by MetaStock.

Silver in rands

Silver price in South African rands: P&F Chart. Chart by MetaStock

In both charts you can see there is an extended sideways pattern in the most recent years with an unbroken horizontal count of 6 in each case.

In US dollars, the horizontal count gives an upside target of $45.92 – more than double its current price.

Mr. Jordaan points out that historically it is normal for gold to move before silver. So, it is entirely possible that in the next few weeks, silver will catch up with gold as it has done in the past.

The only problem is that while both the rand and the US dollar line charts show an upside break, neither yet shows that break in P&F – which is necessary for the horizontal count target to be valid. Valid horizontal count targets in P&F are more than 70% accurate and usually conservative in our experience.


All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

Share this article:


The Confidential Report - December 2021


The US economy is still booming. Weekly jobless claims, for the week ended 20 November 2021, fell 71 000, while consumer spending jumped 1,3% in October month alone. Third quarter gross domestic product (GDP) came in at 2,1% - hammered by supply constraints, but above analysts’ expectations. Unemployment has fallen to 4,6% and

Transaction Capitals Trendline

In last week’s article on Grand Parade, we drew your attention to the importance and usefulness of downward trendlines (drawn above a downward trend) in establishing the best point to buy a share. This week we draw your attention to the benefit of upward trendlines (drawn below a rising trend) as a method of determining when a share, with a strong rising trend, has corrected

Grand Parade Trendlines

Technical analysis, which is the search for and analysis of patterns in share price charts, can become very complex and mathematical. Literally thousands of line indicators have been developed which claim to improve the investor’s probability of being right when determining the moment when a share’s price turns. In our experience, the

Private Investor Advantage

Finding winning shares is not just about looking for quality. It is about finding quality when it is cheap – which usually means finding it when it has fallen heavily and is out of favour with institutional fund managers. We advise you to look for the “mountain behind you” in the chart.

As a private investor

New Record High

As we predicted, the S&P500 reached a new all-time record high on Thursday 21st October 2021 at 4549.78. This officially means that the correction that it was going through is over. That correction took the index down to a closing low of 4300.46 (on 4th October 2021) – which is a 5,2% decline from the cycle high of 4536.95

Hulamin - Insider Trading

In our opinion on Hulamin, last updated on 3rd September 2021, we noted “What is noteworthy about this share is that it has a net asset value (NAV) which is more than 3 times its current share price making it a possible takeover target”.

On Thursday last week the company issued a bland “cautionary” notice


Calgro used to be the darling of the institutional investors. Every fund manager in South Africa was buying the share and it rose dramatically from as little at 50c in February 2011 to an intraday high of 2275c on 11th August 2015. At this point it had a market capitalisation of R2,8bn and was trading on a price:earnings (P:E) ratio of

The Confidential Report - October 2021


The S&P500 is in a correction which began after 2nd September 2021 when it made an all-time record high of 4537. Since then, it has fallen by as much as 249 points to an intra-day low of 4288 on Friday (1/10/21). This correction has taken 20 trading days and amounted to 5,4% at its worst. There are a variety


The context within which a chart is viewed is vital to your understanding of it. In this article we will attempt to show the broader context within which we view the market action which took place last Friday.


Let us focus our attention on the S&P500 index, which is a weighted average of the