The Confidential Report - May 2022

4 May 2022 By PDSNET

Ukraine

The war in Ukraine has shifted. The Russians have given up their efforts to take Kyiv and are now concentrating in the Eastern “Donbas” region where their lines of communication are shorter. Clearly, this has been a major set-back for them and a huge boost for the morale of the Ukrainians. It is becoming apparent that the Russians have committed a much larger proportion of their army to this second, less ambitious, attack from the East, but it does not appear that they have changed their tactics or strategy in any significant way. They are still apparently adopting a World War II “blitzkrieg” approach, hoping to overcome their more agile enemy by sheer weight of numbers and firepower. The Ukrainian army, despite the destruction of some of their cities, has gained enormously from its experiences over the past two months. It has been systematically re-armed by NATO, with the addition of heavy weapons, and now has a formidable force of well-armed and experienced fighters and is clearly capable of making strikes inside Russia. Thus far the battles in the Donbas have been intense and involved heavy losses on both sides. Aside from a few small concessions, Ukraine has hardly lost any ground and something of a stalemate appears to have come about. It remains our view that time is on the side of the Ukrainians. The Russians cannot really afford a long-drawn-out war of attrition.

The Russian economy is taking enormous strain from the double cost of the war and the sanctions which it is enduring. Its ability to continue this war for a significant period must be seriously in doubt. The probability of Russia facing an internal insurrection of some sort is rising as the effects of the war begin to be felt more and more acutely by its population. In our opinion, the re-grouping of the Russian army in the Eastern Donbas region and its renewed attacks represent its final effort to displace Zelensky and gain control of Ukraine. If they fail for a second time, which seems inevitable, given their tactics and the mounting economic pressure on them, then not only will they lose their hold on Ukraine, but Putin will almost certainly loose his control over Russia itself.

There is the possibility that the situation will settle into a position where Russia returns to the situation which existed before the war began but with some small territorial gains, especially on the Black Sea. We believe that this scenario would not be sustainable for Russia because Western economic sanctions will remain in place and their economy (which is only about the size of the American state of Texas) will inevitably collapse, especially if Europe can wean itself off Russian oil and gas.

Our view is that eventually Putin will be ousted from power – probably by someone from within his inner circle. There are already questions around his health and the events in Ukraine have certainly damaged his image as an absolute dictator. What looks now like his inevitable demise will probably be followed by a period of fairly chaotic adjustment, but inevitably, Russia will continue on the path that it was on before this conflict began – that of becoming a modern and ultimately democratic, capitalist European economy. We even see the possibility of it joining the European Union and NATO once the dust has settled sufficiently. In other words, we see this war in Ukraine as probably the final kick in the Soviet authoritarian anachronism.

There is, of course, the outside possibility that the situation could escalate into a nuclear war between Russia and the NATO alliance. Russia’s minister of foreign affairs, Sergey Lavrov has recently been talking about the increased danger of nuclear war. In our view, this is “sabre rattling” and a sign that Russia is becoming increasingly desperate about its chances of obtaining any significant gains in the conventional war. A nuclear war would result in the immediate, complete and utter annihilation of Russia. No doubt, Europe and America would also suffer some horrendous damage, but nothing to compare with that sustained by the Russians. It is impossible to make any reasonable predictions for this scenario. We can only hope that there are those in positions of power within Russia who can see the utter futility of such a course of action and take effective steps to ensure that it does not happen.

In our view, the Ukraine situation has already been substantially discounted into the financial markets of the world and the JSE. Unless there is some unforeseen escalation (such as NATO entering the war directly with “boots on the ground”), we suggest that most equities on the JSE will be impacted less and less by developments. The primary effects for South Africa are probably going to be the raised price of fuel, countered by the benefits to our mining sector from rising commodity prices.

 

America

The comments of the governor of the Federal Reserve Bank (the Fed), Jerome Powell, concerning a 50-basis point rise in interest rates in the US at the monetary policy committee (MPC) meeting in May, combined with the Fed’s intention to reduce the size of its balance sheet by $95bn a month amount to a significant and rapid shift in US monetary policy.

It is clear now that the US has been “behind the curve” because it persisted with the idea that the rise in inflation to above 5% late last year was a temporary phenomenon. Now that inflation has risen in March 2022 to 8,5% it is apparent that the Fed needs to take radical action to contain it.

St. Louis Federal Reserve President, James Bullard, said the U.S. central bank's short-term policy rate should reach 3.5% later this year. For that to happen there will have to be a series of 50-basis-point hikes in interest rates in the coming months. At the same time, Fed officials have "generally agreed" to cut up to $95 billion a month from the central bank's asset holdings – a process which is known as quantitative tightening (QT) and is the opposite of quantitative easing (QE). Investors are now projecting a 90% likelihood of a 50 basis-point rate hike at the central bank's meeting this month, followed by further 50-basis-point hikes during the rest of 2022. That perception is the main underlying cause of the current bearishness on Wall Street.

At the same time, analysts on average are expecting S&P 500 companies' earnings to have grown 6.4% in the March quarter and so far, they have been exceeding that forecast comfortably.

Nearly a third of the companies on the S&P 500 have reported results this week. Overall, earnings have been better than expected, with nearly 80% of the 176 companies in the S&P 500 that have reported so far beating Wall Street expectations. 

From a technical perspective, the bitter fighting in the Donbas region of Ukraine added additional risk to a market that was already falling because of the hawkish stance of the US Federal Reserve Bank (the Fed) and on Friday last week that finally carried the S&P500 down through the support level at 4170. Consider the chart:

S&P500 Index: December 2021 - 3rd May 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

The above chart shows the progress of the major correction in the S&P500 index this year. After the “double bottom” in early March 2022 we thought that the correction had seen its lowest closing level, but we did not count on two developments – firstly that the Fed’s governor, Jerome Powell, would come out with an overtly bearish remark and secondly that the fighting in Ukraine would reach a new level of intensity in the Donbas. These two events have combined to take the index down through 4170 to a new low. However, you will note that the low is still slightly above the intraday low of 4114 which was made on 24th February 2022.

Given the better-than expected quarterly results coming out of those S&P500 companies that have reported so far and the current strength of the US economy, we believe that the S&P will recover. However, it is worth remembering that in our Confidential Report published on 3rd November 2021 we predicted this correction 2 months before it started and said that it could take the S&P down to as low as 3680. At this time, we certainly do not see the S&P falling that far – but given the break down through support at 4170 it could certainly fall further.

Despite this, we still remain confident that this is a correction and not the start of a new bear trend. For this reason, we continue to see it as a buying opportunity.

 

The Economy

Before looking at developments in the economy this month, we thought it constructive to consider its progress in the light of internationally accepted standards for the reform of emerging economies. We believe that after 28 years in power, most of them with a significant majority, the ANC has had plenty of opportunity to implement economic reforms.

 

The Washington Consensus

In 1989, an English economist, John Williamson, came up with a set of ten principals for the reform of emerging markets and developing economies which became known as the Washington Consensus because they were very widely accepted by those international institutions based in Washington (such as the IMF, the World Bank and the US Treasury). At the time that Williamson put forward these ideas, the USSR was busy unraveling with the collapse of the Berlin Wall and the reforms were seen as the best mechanism for Russia to become a thriving capitalist economy.

It is useful and interesting to consider the ten principals of the Washington Consensus as they apply to the South African economy. The effectiveness of the reform process has a direct impact on the performance of the JSE. The steadily declining number of listed shares over the past ten years is an overt symptom of state capture.

The ten Washington Consensus principals of economic reform are:

 

  1. Fiscal policy discipline, with avoidance of large fiscal deficits relative to GDP.

    Fiscal discipline was excellent in South Africa while Trevor Manuel was the Minister of Finance, but since his departure debt levels have been allowed to rise, especially during the Zuma years and with the systematic looting of state coffers through state capture. Since the advent of the Ramaphosa administration enormous efforts have been made to bring the deficit down and with the help of the tax bonanza from the commodity boom it is now coming back under control.

  2. Redirection of public spending from subsidies ("especially indiscriminate subsidies") toward broad-based provision of key pro-growth, pro-poor services like primary education, primary health care and infrastructure investment.

    Since the ANC came into power 28 years ago, the pro-growth, pro-poor services mentioned above have suffered. Health care, education and infrastructure development have been set aside in favour of the five social relief grants (i.e., subsidies) which absorb some 60% of the government’s non-interest spending. In effect the government is subsidising people who do not or cannot work instead of empowering them with education and proper health care.

  3. Tax reform, broadening the tax base and adopting moderate marginal tax rates.

    There can be little doubt that since the Ramaphosa administration took over a significant effort has been made to improve the collection of taxes and undo the damage done by Tom Moyane and state capture, but there is a long way to go. The tax base remains narrow with a massive and growing “informal sector” – which is really a euphemism for tax evasion. The corporate tax rate has been reduced and tax collections have improved mainly due to the commodity bonanza that the country is currently enjoying.

  4. Interest rates that are market determined and positive (but moderate) in real terms.

    Monetary policy stability has been probably the single greatest achievement of the ANC government over the past 28 years and right through the Zuma period of state capture. Indeed, the Reserve Bank and the Judiciary are almost the only two organs of state that were not captured. The low level of inflation and relative stability of the rand are the envy of other emerging economies and have helped us to weather the storm of COVID-19. The rand remains one of only five emerging market currencies that have actually appreciated against the US dollar this year.

  5. Competitive exchange rates.

    This factor is connected to the effective monetary policy mentioned above. The benefits of having a currency that is stable against first world currencies cannot be over-emphasised. A stable currency instils confidence in the economy for both local and overseas investors. If our currency was subject to rampant inflation and falling against overseas currencies, we would be unable to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) and the economy would be spiralling down in the same way as many African economies. Our currency is traded in a very free and competitive market which has made it the benchmark emerging market currency.

  6. Trade liberalization: liberalization of imports, with particular emphasis on elimination of quantitative restrictions (licensing, etc.); any trade protection to be provided by low and relatively uniform tariffs.

    This is a thorny subject. Opening the economy to free trade is obviously ideal from an economic point of view. However, the South African government has seen fit to impose tariffs on imported chicken, cement, and steel to name just three products. These are high bulk, relatively low value products which are expensive to import from other countries – and yet the Pakistanis are able to produce and transport cement here more cheaply than we can make it here. The same applies to chicken. Obviously if you apply tariffs to an import, you immediately make that product more expensive for local consumers. Since chicken is the primary source of protein in this country the government should allow it in duty-free and if local producers cannot compete, they should be allowed to go out of business.

  7. Liberalization of inward foreign direct investment.

    President Ramaphosa has made this his personal mission with a fair degree of success. Through his annual investment conferences, he has managed to attract considerable investment. But the policies of BEE and the onerous labour laws which are skewed heavily in favour of employees have tended to keep investors away. Obviously, the stability of the rand has been a major positive factor as is the very well-developed and stable commercial banking sector.

  8. Privatisation of state enterprises.

    This is another political “hot potato” to the extent that the very term “privatisation” has become taboo in government circles. Despite this there is a recognition that certain of the state-owned enterprises (SOE) would be better off if they were partially or completely financed and managed by private enterprise. The example of Telkom, which is managed privately, but in which the government still effectively holds a controlling stake is important. It shows that private enterprise generally manages large organisations better than government. More recently, SAA is in the process of being taken over by private enterprise, with significant government support. The principal is that if it is at all possible for an enterprise to be privately owned and managed rather than in government hands – it should be. A number of examples of inefficient SOEs come to mind – the Post Office, Denel, the SABC and so on. Privatisation can also result in an inflow of funds into the Treasury which could be used to reduce the government deficit.

  9. Deregulation: abolition of regulations that impede market entry or restrict competition, except for those justified on safety, environmental and consumer protection grounds, and prudential oversight of financial institutions.

    Since it took control of South Africa the ANC has presided over a deluge of legislation much of which is openly ignored and some of which impedes business. Efforts have been made to reduce legislation and eliminate red tape and the entire informal sector operates substantially outside the law. However, establishing a small business and complying with all the rules in South Africa remains onerous. Small business is the largest employer in the economy and should obviously be encouraged. The consensus identifies four areas where legislation is justified – safety, environmental protection, consumer protection and prudential oversight. It is clear that legislation in South Africa goes well beyond this at a significant cost to the economy and job creation.

  10. Legal security for property rights.

    The distribution of land in this country is highly contentious and has been the subject of much populist rhetoric. For an economy to grow it is important that property rights be seen as sacrosanct. The attempts to enable expropriation without compensation are seen by overseas investors as highly negative. They work against Ramaphosa’s efforts to encourage FDI.

The South African economy over the Zuma period has also suffered from a toxic combination of indolence, corruption and incompetence which fed heavily into state capture. In our view, the failure to adhere to the full spectrum of the Washington Consensus has certainly impeded progress and economic prosperity in South Africa, while those principals which have been adhered to have saved this country from following so many African economies and becoming a “banana republic.”    

 

Economy

Consumer prices (inflation) rose to 5,9% in March 2022 – which is very close to the upper end of the Reserve Bank’s target range of between 3% and 6%. This will certainly result in the monetary policy committee (MPC) raising rates again by a further 0,25% at its next meeting and probably by 0,5%. There will probably be hikes at the following two MPC meetings later this year as well. The MPC is intent on keeping interest rates in South Africa well ahead of interest rates in America and Europe to ensure continued overseas investment in South African bonds. Obviously, the danger of raising rates too quickly would be to halt the nascent recovery in the economy this year. The inflation rate is being pushed up by rising fuel and rising food costs – both of which are linked to the war in Ukraine. The jump in the producer price index (PPI) to 11,9% in March 2022 was much sharper than the 10.7% predicted by economists. This means that a 50-basis point hike in interest rates at the MPC meeting this month is probably inevitable. This unexpected rise in the PPI was caused mainly by fuel and food prices. The inflation rate in South Africa is expected to peak at around 6% in the coming months and then to tail off to levels below 5% next year. At this stage, rates remain relatively accommodative and stimulatory, but as they rise listed companies will begin to experience greater pressure. The economy has grown more quickly than was expected so far this year, mostly because of the boom in commodity prices, but future growth may be erratic.

The latest report of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) is that South Africa will be protected from a downturn in the growth of the world economy due to its exports of raw materials. It warns that world inflation will remain higher for longer and that central banks will tighten their monetary policy in response. Obviously, the war in Ukraine has become a major factor and will impact on the growth of the world economy – mainly because of the rise in the oil price. The inflationary impact of rising energy costs will cause already hawkish central banks to become more so in their efforts to keep inflation under control. Inflation in South Africa is expected to peak at 5,7% in 2022, falling to 4,6% in 2023. So far, South Africa has remained ahead of the interest rate tightening cycle and may be able to avoid the 50-basis point hikes expected in America and elsewhere because of its relatively low inflation.

New car sales are a very good indication of economic growth. Consumers and businesses can always put off buying a new car when cash flow is constrained – so a jump in new car sales is an indication that confidence is returning. In March 2022 new car sales were more than 50600 – that’s up 16,5% on the same month last year and the best sales level since October 2019. Obviously, despite the three 0,25% rises in the interest rates and the prospect of further rises, rates are still on the low side and that encourages people to finance vehicle purchases. Motor vehicle exports were down 12,4% but will probably recover as the Ukraine crisis comes under control.

The flooding in Natal comes on top of the impact of the civil unrest in July 2021 and has left a number of businesses struggling. A state of disaster was declared in the province and has been followed by a national state of disaster to enable it to access government funding for relief. The president visited the affected areas and promised support. The record flooding has been linked to climate change although there is no direct connection. Our view is that natural disasters of this sort are going to become more commonplace and increase in intensity as climate change takes hold. A number of listed companies including Sappi and Pepkor have issued stock exchange news service (SENS) announcements on the damage which they had incurred. Both of these companies have adequate insurance to cover the damage. Obviously, the flooding will have a significant impact on insurance companies. The damage to the sugar cane industry has been significant with some analysts suggesting the industry itself may not survive and hundreds of small cane growers will probably cease to operate.

The theft of metal infrastructure in South Africa is reaching dysfunctional proportions. Current figures are that metal theft costs organisations like Telkom, Transnet and Eskom about R7bn a year. However, this direct cost is dwarfed by the knock-on costs to the economy of cable theft, the theft of rails and other infrastructure. That cost is estimated to be more than R180bn per annum. A substantial proportion of the stolen metal is exported. The CEO of Scaw Metals says that at the moment a cut down Eskom pylon is selling for around R9000 per ton, making theft of vital infrastructure a highly profitable business. Clearly, the police are completely unable to control the theft despite an increase in the number of arrests and convictions over the last few years. This is a problem which is crippling South African industry and making everyone poorer.

Mining which used to be the backbone of the economy has shrunk substantially since the ANC took power. The unfriendly empowerment regulations are added to an erratic and expensive electricity supply and Transnet’s frequent inability to get minerals to port for export. The combination of the factors has made South Africa one of the least attractive destinations for mining investment in the world – and even in Africa. There is a backlog of more than 4000 applications for mining licences which have not been processed due to government inefficiency and bureaucracy. At a time when the country faces an official unemployment rate of over 35%, the mining sector, which used to be one of the largest employers in the country, has been consistently prejudiced. If this government wants to improve the unemployment situation and attract foreign direct investment (FDI) they need to reform the mining industry.

Eskom’s fleet of coal-fired power stations is now 43 years old on average, which means that it is subject to unscheduled breakdowns on a regular basis. In the year to the end of March 2022, Eskom spent R7bn to run diesel turbines to compensate for its inefficient fleet of power stations which are only able to manage a 60% availability. The return to stage 4 loadshedding in April 2022 is a blow to the economy which is just recovering from COVID-19 and the impact of the July 2021 civil unrest. Over the next three years it is estimated that about 8 gigawatts of power will be added to the grid from renewable energy sources – and it is apparent that Eskom is relying on this new supply. The current supply shortfall is about 6 gigawatts. By 2025 when the additional capacity may be available, the demand for Eskom’s electricity may be considerably lower as consumers and businesses find alternative solutions. The regular price hikes from Eskom are also pricing it out of the market. In our view, Eskom will probably cease to exist as a power generation entity by the end of this decade. Frustration with the new bout of load-shedding has led to public spats between Eskom board members and the Standing Committee on Public Accounts (SCOPA). President Ramaphosa has had to intervene to calm the situation. At the same time, the Department of Mineral and Energy Affairs has postponed, for the fifth time, the deadline for financial commitment to the winning bidders in the emergency power procurement program. This means that the deadline is now a year behind its original date.

 

The Rand

In the week between 14th and 22nd April 2022, the rand took a beating falling almost 6% – mainly because of the remarks of US Federal Reserve Bank chair, Jerome Powell. Alarmed by a 40-year high in inflation which hit 8,5% in America in March 2022, Powell indicated that interest rates would rise by 50 basis points at the next monetary policy committee (MPC) meeting in May 2022. This has caused a shift towards “risk-on” amongst international investors and a consequent fall in emerging market currencies. Despite this fall, the rand remains one of only 5 out of the 31 emerging market currencies to have appreciated against the US dollar this year. This can be attributed to the continuing bonanza in commodity prices which has resulted in a steady flow of hard currencies into the country and enabled it to reduce its government deficit. There is little doubt that the Fed has lagged behind other countries in adopting a tighter monetary policy. It has only passed one 0,25% increase in rates where South Africa has already increased rates three times by a total of 0,75%. We expect that the South African MPC will raise rates by a further 50 basis points at its next meeting to stay ahead of rate hikes in first world countries and particularly America. Consider the chart:

South African rand/US dollar: October 2020 - 3rd May 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro

You can see that prior to the civil unrest in July 2021 the rand had been strengthening against the US dollar. The riots sparked a period of weakness which lasted until December and then a new strengthening trend began. When the war in Ukraine broke out, the rand weakened a little in response to new risk-off sentiment, but basically held its ground. Only when the US Federal Reserve Bank began to get seriously worried about inflation did the rand fall heavily.

Right now, the investment community is busy digesting the new, much more hawkish stance of the Fed so stock markets have fallen and the rand is treading water at weaker levels. We expect it to strengthen as the news is more fully discounted.  

 

General

The government’s decision to force all government departments to use the South African Post Office’s (SAPO) services wherever possible is counter-productive. It is well known that SAPO is hugely inefficient and has completely lost its market in the private sector due to poor performance. To force government departments to use its services in order to rescue SAPO financially will simply make those departments less efficient than they already are. It is a retrogressive step and shows a comprehensive misunderstanding of how a modern economy works. Postnet and various courier companies have grown precisely because of the inefficiencies of the Post Office just as Curro and other companies have grown because of the sharp decline in the quality of education at government schools. In our opinion, SAPO, Denel, the SABC and SAA should all cease to exist – because they are incapable of competing and are costing the taxpayer money unnecessarily.

It is difficult to know whether we can take the ANC’s “discussion document” leaked to the Business Day on 25th April 2022 seriously. Along with some populist rhetoric, the paper proposes that business acquire a stake in certain key state owned enterprises in what looks very much like a degree of privatization. It seems that the government has become aware that its efforts to create jobs from within government are counter-productive and it would do better to get private enterprise involved. The document is to be tabled at the ANC’s conference later in 2022 and is perhaps an indication of President Ramaphosa’s confidence that he will not be recalled or seriously opposed at that meeting.

The Social Relief of Distress grant (SRD) of R350 per month which was given to indigent people following COVID-19 and then extended for a year at a cost of R44bn to taxpayers has been found to have been subject to rampant fraud. More than 25000 fraudulent payments been made, including more than 5800 to government employees. This is part of a pattern of corruption which plagues every aspect of government activity and which is a serious burden to the country. It seems that whatever program the government decides to undertake, there is going to be a large fraudulent component. Obviously, fraud costs the taxpayer heavily and acts as a disincentive to projects like the SRD.

Finance Minister, Enoch Godongwana’s approval of an investigation into the running of the Cape Town metropolitan rail system is a significant shift in ANC policy. Until now the government has blocked efforts by Cape Town’s provincial government to take over the management of the rail system for political reasons. But that system has virtually collapsed with only 33 working train sets, down from 95 train sets in 1995. Godongwana is apparently in favour of removing the state-owned enterprise (SOE), Prasa from an important function which it has performed so badly for decades. The shift is also a boost for the city of Cape Town because it means that an effective efficient rail transport system can be implemented, but it is also a major step towards the government reducing its size and showing a willingness to let go of functions for which it is not well suited.

 

Commodities

Oil

In our view, the war in Ukraine is likely to be relatively short-term, if only because Russia cannot afford to continue prosecuting a war while enduring extremely heavy sanctions. Already it is apparent that the oil price has probably topped out and is now falling back to more reasonable levels. We expect this “normalization” to continue.

North Sea Brent Oil: February 2020 - 3rd May 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

You can see in this chart of North Sea Brent oil that following the advent of COVID-19 in April 2020, the price of oil began to rise steadily in a clearly defined channel that was broken on the upside by the Ukraine crisis in March 2022. The price reached a peak of $125 per barrel and has since been trending down. Russia’s supply of oil to world markets is being steadily replaced by supply from the Middle East. Most European countries and especially Germany are actively trying to reduce their dependence on Russian supply. We expect the oil price to remain volatile, but to continue declining.  

 

Companies

SIBANYE

The Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (AMCU) and the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) have been on strike at Sibanye’s gold mines since 9th March 2022 – which has so far cost miners more than R1bn in lost wages. Now the unions, seeing that they not getting a positive response from management have given notice of extending the strike to Sibanye’s platinum group metals (PGM) operations in a so-called “sympathy strike”. Obviously, the loss of gold production is costing Sibanye, but its gold mining operation in South Africa only accounts for about 7% of its total revenue. Extending the strike to its PGM operations will certainly increase the cost to Sibanye – provided, of course, that the PGM workers are willing to forgo their wages to assist their colleagues in the gold industry which doesn’t seem likely. The unions have rejected a sweetened offer by Sibanye and vowed to continue their strike. They justify this by pointing to Neal Froneman’s recently announced massive R300m annual earnings. The offer by Sibanye to unions now beats inflation by a wide margin, but they have become fixated on Froneman’s earnings and the enormous disparity which exists between the highest and lowest paid workers in the company. Notably, at the same time that this is going on, the bus drivers have just accepted a 6% wage increase – which is well below what the Sibanye workers are being offered. It is a fact that, in a capitalist economy, remuneration levels vary substantially depending on the work done, the worker’s qualifications and experience as well as the relative scarcity of that type of employee. The socialist concept of everyone earning more-or-less the same has never been a part of capitalism. Consider the chart:

Sibanye Stillwater (SSW): January 2018 - 29 April 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

As you can see here Sibanye has been in a strong upward trend for the past 4 years with the share price rising from just over R7 to current levels around R55. Clearly, the strike is not having a major impact on investor perceptions. We expect this share to continue rising over time.

 

CLICKS

The Clicks results for the six months to 28th February 2022 were excellent as usual. The company reported group turnover up 9% and headline earnings per share (HEPS) up 26%. The company returned R1,3bn to shareholders in dividends and share buy-backs. The company said, " Retail sales grew by 13.6%, with selling price inflation of 3.7%. Distribution turnover increased by 0.6%, with price inflation of 1.9% for the  first half. Inventory levels were well managed and group inventory days reduced to 78 days (H1 2021: 83 days). Retail inventory days improved from 85 to 81 days and UPD from 56 to 49 days". We urge you, once again, to buy this share on any weakness and include it in your long-term portfolio. The share closed at 590c on 11th March 2002. Today it trades for over R310 per share – and during that 20-year period it has given regular returns to shareholders culminating in the R1,3bn given in this latest six months. Consider the exponential chart:

Clicks (CLS): January 2003 - 29 April 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

 

CORONATION

Just over ten years ago on 9th January 2012, I bought a parcel of Coronation (CML) shares for R23.20 per share. My reasons were relatively simple – here was a financial services company that was growing rapidly and beginning to attract the attention of institutional fund managers. And it was very cheap on a dividend yield (DY) of 7,41%. Normally, any reasonable quality share on a DY of 5% or more is worth considering. The reason for this is that most quality shares trade on a DY of around 2,5% - which means that a share on a DY of 5% is trading at about half what it could be worth. If course, it must be a quality share with a solid growth in earnings and a substantial volume of shares changing hand each day, otherwise the big institutions will not be interested. In January 2012, after careful consideration I decided that Coronation was fundamentally undervalued and that sooner or later the big institutions would realise this and begin buying it. Consider the chart:

Coronation (CML): November 2011 - 29 April 2022. Chart by ShareFriendPro.

 

Over the next three years the share went up consistently, eventually reaching a peak of R115 at the end of 2014. Then the CEO of the company resigned, and the share began to fall. I sold out reluctantly for R94 which was my stop-loss level – and as you can see from the chart above the share has been in a downward trend since then. COVID-19 took it down to a low of around R25 in March/April 2020, but it has recovered somewhat since then. The point is that today it is once again trading for a high DY of 8,99%. In any event, if and when the share breaks up through its long-term downward trendline it will certainly be worth considering.

 

PEPKOR

In their latest trading statement for the six months to 31st March 2022, Pepkor estimated that headline earnings per share (HEPS) would increase by between 22,3% and 31,9%. This is a significant achievement in the current economic environment and following the floods in Natal. Pepkor has been an amazing success story over years catering to the low-income group’s clothing needs. Consider the chart:

Pepkor (PPH): January 2020 - 29 April 2022. Chart by ShareFriendPro.

 

As you can see here, the share fell heavily along with all retailers during COVID-19 in March 2020. It then moved sideways in an “island formation” with strong support at R10 per share. Beginning in November 2020 it began to recover and has been moving up since then. We believe that this share will continue to perform well as the economy recovers.

 

SOUTH32

As the commodity boom continues, it is worth considering diversified international mining houses. South 32 (S32) was spun out of BHP Billiton in 2015 and contained all of BHP's South African coal assets. It is, in its own right, a diversified miner of base metals and minerals such as zinc, coal, aluminium, silver, lead, nickel and manganese. It operates in South Africa, South America, and Australia. The company has separated out its coal assets in South Africa and especially those which supply Eskom, into a separate entity which was sold on 1st June 2020 to Seriti. At the same time the company has announced that it has bought the remaining 83% of Arizona Mining which it did not already own. Arizona Mining has extensive interests in zinc, manganese and silver described by South 32's CEO, Graham Kerr, as "...one of the most exciting base metal projects in the world". Clearly, this is another international mining house that is distancing itself from South Africa because of the administrative and legislative uncertainty here. Kerr has stated that "...mining exploration is out of the question in South Africa until the new mining charter is finalised". The company is continuing with its $1,4bn share buy-back. The company is working to supply its Hillside smelter with renewable energy and transition away from Eskom over the next 10 years. In its results for the six months to 31st December 2021 the company reported revenue up 61,2% and headline earnings per share (HEPS) of 22,8c compared with 1,8c in the previous period. The company said, "We achieved a record operating margin of 44% and a significant improvement in our Underlying earnings to US$1.0B in the half, following a broad recovery in commodity prices, while also making substantial progress reshaping our portfolio". Consider the chart:

South32 (S32): January 2020 - 29 April 2022. Chart by ShareFriend Pro.

 

As you can see, following the COVID19 downtrend, this share has been recovering. That recovery was initially slow until September 2021 and then it began to accelerate. This is partly due to the fact that it has new base metal interests, some of which may be very exciting. We consider the share, although volatile, to have further upside potential.


DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.



Share this article:

The Confidential Report - Archives

The Confidential Report - June 2022

In the past month the systematic risk in the market has increased noticeably. In our experience, investors do not usually pay sufficient attention to systematic risk, especially during a protracted bull market. Investor attention is focused more on selecting specific shares than on the risk that the market as a whole might fall. Systematic risk can very

The Confidential Report - April 2022

Central Europe

The crisis in Ukraine has taken center stage in the markets of the world, pushing aside the lingering impact of COVID-19 and the growing specter of rising world inflation. In our assessment, the war in Ukraine is the final kick in the death of the erstwhile USSR. That superpower was reduced to modern-day Russia following its disastrous

The Confidential Report - March 2022

Ukraine

Obviously, the news which has gripped markets over the past month is the troubles in Central Europe. To get a better understanding of what might happen to markets going forward, it is necessary to make some assumptions about how the situation in Ukraine is likely to develop. Firstly, it seems clear to us that neither NATO nor Russia are willing to get

The Confidential Report - February 2022

America

Internationally and in South Africa, the big story in financial markets is the shift which we predicted from “dovish” to “hawkish” among the central banks of the world. The new trend was initiated in the US Federal Reserve Bank’s monetary policy committee (MPC) minutes which anticipate an end to

The Confidential Report - December 2021

America

The US economy is still booming. Weekly jobless claims, for the week ended 20 November 2021, fell 71 000, while consumer spending jumped 1,3% in October month alone. Third quarter gross domestic product (GDP) came in at 2,1% - hammered by supply constraints, but above analysts’ expectations. Unemployment has fallen to 4,6% and

The Confidential Report - October 2021

America

The S&P500 is in a correction which began after 2nd September 2021 when it made an all-time record high of 4537. Since then, it has fallen by as much as 249 points to an intra-day low of 4288 on Friday (1/10/21). This correction has taken 20 trading days and amounted to 5,4% at its worst. There are a variety

The Confidential Report - September 2021

America

The suggestion by the Federal Reserve Bank (Fed) that it may begin to reduce its monthly asset buying program from $120bn per month before the end of 2021 sent markets into a new mini-correction. The process of reducing this type of quantitative easing (Q/E) has become known as “tapering” and the Fed’s consideration

The Confidential Report - August 2021

America

Current estimates are that the US economy will grow at the rate of 6,6% overall this year and as much as 8,3% in the third quarter. S&P500 companies continue to produce record-breaking profits. The growth in GDP is truly enormous for such a large economy and will clearly cause the boom in commodity

The Confidential Report - July 2021

America

The US inflation rate rose to 5% in May 2021 – up from April’s 4,2% and March’s 2,6%. At the same time, there is evidence that employee costs (i.e. wages) are rising at the rate of 2,8% on average. Employees are also changing jobs more rapidly with the “quit rate” rising to 2,7%. This shows that employees are moving

The Confidential Report - June 2021

America

In the previous Confidential Report on 5th May 2021, when the S&P500 index was at 4167, we suggested that it was probably due for a correction. Over the last month we have watched as a correction unfolded in that index. However, it turned out to be only a mini-correction of just 4% - and as we pointed out in our article, 

The Confidential Report - May 2021

America
The US economy grew at an annualized rate of 6,4% in the first quarter of 2021 – which was much faster than expected. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was $19,1 trillion – which can be compared to the $19,3 trillion of the December quarter of 2019 - before the pandemic took hold. This shows that the economy is now virtually back to pre-COVID-19 levels. The