ARTICLES

Astoria

Astoria (ARA) is an investment holding company listed on the Alt-X of the JSE and also on the Stock Exchange of Mauritius (SEM). It has a market capitalization of R614m and trades on a P:E ratio of 15,14 – which compares to the JSE’s average P:E of 10,48.

The share is currently trading at a 22% discount to its net asset value (NAV) of 1408c. It is quite normal for the shares of investment holding companies to trade on the JSE at a discount to their NAV. Sometimes they decide to “unbundle” their holdings into the hands of their shareholders to release that unrealized value, but sometimes the discount makes them an attractive take-over prospect.

We added Astoria to the Winning Shares List (WSL) on 18^th July 2023 when the shares closed at 1000c. Our primary reason for adding it was that it had published a “cautionary” in which it said that it was involved in “negotiations” which might result in the company being acquired. We felt that, since it was trading at a discount to its NAV, it probably represented good value for a prospective buyer. We were also motivated by the fact that, although thinly traded, the share had been trending upwards for some time. Consider the chart:

On 2^nd August 2023 Astoria published its results for the six months to the end of June 2023. These results showed that its NAV had fallen in US dollars by 9,6% but had remained virtually the same in rands – because the rand had fallen by 10,8% against the US dollar over the period.

In those results, Astoria gave a detailed list of the various investments that it held on 30^th June 2023. Where the investments were unlisted, the company provided a directors’ valuation.

Almost half of the company’s NAV (47,5%) is invested in a 40% stake in Outdoor Investment Holdings (OIH). This business is focused on catering to the safari and outdoor hunting market. This is a niche market aimed at wealthy, mostly American and local gun-lovers and hunters. With the strong economy currently being experienced in America, many people are deciding to indulge their life-long ambition to “bag” one or more of the Big Five game animals only available in Africa. At the same time South Africans have been buying weapons for self-protection.

The directors of Astoria value their unlisted investments like OIH at 6 times their earnings before interest and taxation (EBIT) minus their net debt. OH has seen an increase in profits and a reduction in its debt leading to a high valuation. Astoria received a dividend of R6,9m from Outdoor Investment Holdings after the end of the half year.

22,6% of Astoria’s NAV is a 25,1% investment in Transhex diamond mining company which has seen lower production and diamond prices. This is a sound operation, but clearly dependent on the international demand for and the prices of diamonds – which makes its profitability volatile. Nonetheless, Astoria received a R7,5m dividend from Transhex during the period.

The company has a policy of re-investing the dividends it receives back into its portfolio of investments.

The company is almost completely debt-free – which reduces the investment risk for private investors substantially.

So, in our view, Astoria would be a good investment – even if it were not a take-over prospect.

DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

PDSNET ARTICLES

Bitcoin's Collapse

We have said previously that cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin cannot be assessed using fundamental analysis – because they have no fundamentals. They have no balance sheet or income statement, and they generate no income for investors. For this reason, they can only be assessed technically - by looking at the charts.

Speculative Opportunity

PDSnet is mainly concerned with teaching private investors about investment and medium to long-term opportunities on the JSE. The foundation of this approach is that South African tax law treats any gain on a share held for longer than 3 years as a capital gain. In other words, holding a share for more than 3 years means that the investor will not be treated as

Scary Government Debt

Just like a household or an individual, a country’s government goes into debt because it spends more than it receives in taxes and other revenue. The important difference, of course, is that governments (unlike households or individuals) can actually create money out of nothing to finance their deficit if they choose to. This is known as quantitative easing (Q/E).

Correction

On the 10^th of July 2024, we tweeted (on “X”) that “...some sort of correction is looking more and more likely.” Four trading days later on the 16th of July 2024, The S&P500 index reached its highest point (5667.2) and began that correction. So far, the S&P has fallen 8,5%. Consider the chart:

WeBuyCars - Follow-up

WeBuyCars (WBC) was spun out of Transaction Capital (TCP) and separately listed on the JSE on 11^th April 2024 – just over three months ago. Before the listing we published an article on the 8th of April 2024, in which we suggested that the share would be a solid blue-chip

Bell Equipment

We are often asked what prompts us to add a share to the Winning Shares List. The answer is that it is a variety of factors – but usually because the share appears to be very cheap in relation to its fundamentals. In other words, we expect it to be upwardly re-rated as its fundamental value becomes recognised by the institutional fund managers. A

JSE All Time Record High

On Friday last week, the 12th of July 2024, the JSE Overall index closed at 81686 – an all-time record high. Consider the chart:

The chart shows that the Overall

Construction

The entire construction industry was decimated by the 2008 sub-prime crisis, the ANC under Jaco Zuma’s presidency and then finally by the pandemic in 2020. Hundreds of thousands of jobs were lost and massive companies like M&R were reduced to penny stocks on the JSE.

The JSE Construction and Materials Index (JS5011)

Murray & Roberts

A company’s debt is critical in establishing the risk inherent when investing in its shares. High debt levels expose the company to high interest and capital payments and can swallow up a large part of whatever profits it makes. Low debt levels give the company the headroom to invest in further growth either organically

Mr Price

Mr Price is a well-known and focused retailer of clothing in South Africa. It is a quintessentially South African company, and its performance is a direct reflection of the state of the economy and the level of consumer spending. It is an extremely well-managed company in a very tough and competitive market. Clothing is sold by many dedicated outlets in South Africa and almost