ARTICLES

Shoprite

15 April 2024 By PDSNET

In their article on 10^th April 2024, Checkers sweeps Pick n Pay as it opens 5 new stores in one day., Businesstech drew attention to the fact that Shoprite had taken over five stores from Pick ‘n Pay on the East Rand. Pick ‘n Pay got into a legal battle with its franchisee over unpaid debts and the franchisee made a deal with Shoprite, the owner of Checkers. The thrust of the article was that Shoprite was continuing to take significant market share away from Pick ‘n Pay.

Of course, Shoprite has been doing very well for many years in its competition with other supermarkets, but the question private investors have to ask is:

 “Is it a good investment?”

You will probably have noticed that the Shoprite share price has been falling during 2024, despite its excellent results. Consider the chart:

Here you can see that the share closed at an all-time record high at 27632c on 8^th January 2024. After that it has been in a downward channel between upper and lower support lines until it broke down on 18^th March 2024 and has been falling further since then.

As a private investor you might find it difficult to understand why a company which is doing so well has a share price which is falling. The reason is that investors had simply pushed the share price too high. On the day that it made that record high it had a P:E of 25,23 – which is very high for a grocery retailer, no matter how well it is doing. For context, on 8^th January 2024, the JSE Overall index had an average P:E of around 10,5 – so Shoprite was trading at more than twice the market’s average.

A key component of a share’s value at any given price is the nature of is business. Some businesses are very easy to manage while others are very difficult. On the scale from easiest to most difficult, retail grocery chains, like Shoprite, are not the most difficult, but they are certainly among the most difficult.

This is because they have huge working capital requirements, a substantial capital investment, a large usually unionised staff complement and paper-thin margins. These characteristics make it very difficult to manage a supermarket chain and make profits.

Even Shoprite with its enormous footprint made a trading profit of R6,67bn in the six months to 31^st December 2024 – which is just 5,9% of its merchandise sales for the same period. Their headline profit was even smaller at 3%. So, if they sell R100 worth of groceries, they are making just R3 profit on that.

You should compare this to a service business which typically has almost no working capital, relatively few high-quality staff and very high margins. A business like Multichoice (MCG), for example, receives debit orders from its 21,7 million subscribers every month.

Their overheads are probably covered before the month starts. Roughly speaking, Shoprite only covers its costs and makes a profit on the last day of the month. So, at its current P:E of 21,3, despite its excellent performance, Shoprite is probably still over-priced and has the potential to fall further.

Almost 33 years ago on 17^th October 1991, Shoprite shares closed at 64c. On Friday last week, they closed at 23956c – and that was after falling 13,3% from their record high of 27632c. Throughout that 33 years the company has paid regular dividends. Last year’s dividend was 663c per share.

At some point the institutional fund managers will begin to buy them again and the share will begin to go up. The question is, “Exactly when?” and there is no good way to answer it. You could, of course, take the attitude that Shoprite is a good long-term investment and simply accumulate it on weakness.

DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

Share this article:

PDSNET ARTICLES - JANUARY 2021

Elimination of the Bears

As far back as January 2016, billionaire George Soros went short on the S&P500 index. This means that he thought the S&P500 was going to fall heavily and he took positions which would profit from a major fall in that index. Later in May 2017 he doubled up on those “short” positions and he has been taking more short positions ever since. As recently as final quarter of 2020 he bought

Truworths

Truworths (TRU) is a retailer of fashionware in South Africa and the UK. As such its business has been damaged by the impact of Brexit in the UK and the recessionary conditions in the South African economy. Both countries have then been impacted by lockdowns which prevented in-store sales for a period of time, beginning in late March 2020. The second wave of the pandemic has also been a factor. In the UK,

The Coming Blow-off

At the start of 2021, it is as well to stand back and consider the context of where world markets are as they slavishly follow Wall Street up to new record highs.  Consider the 12-year chart of the S&P500:

 
The chart shows that the great bull market which began in March 2009 is on-going. It is moving within a clearly defined channel.

Window Dressing

We all know that our market, the JSE, is dominated by the big institutions – the pension funds, unit trusts, insurance companies and a scattering of large fund managers. These institutions together account for at least 90% of the trades on the JSE by value. We private investors make up the rest.
Big institutions have huge holdings of mostly blue-chip or