ARTICLES

Learning from Steinhoff

The Steinhoff debacle, which really came to an end on Wednesday when they published their re-stated financial results for the 2017 year (reported in Business Day of 9^th May 2019), contains some vital lessons for private investors.

The financials reveal a web of companies which were used by a group of unscrupulous executives to move money around, overstate profits and obscure fraudulent transactions.

Clearly, the investing public and even the highly-qualified and experienced analysts at various asset management companies like Coronation, Allan Gray and the Public Investment Corporation (PIC) were fooled into thinking that Steinhoff was a solid blue chip company which was growing rapidly.

Steinhoff’s financial results were analysed exhaustively. Steinhoff executives were interviewed and questioned about various aspects of the business. Auditors did numerous spot checks of the figures and wrote clean audit reports. Nobody realized until it was too late that the structure and the published results were just “smoke and mirrors”.

How can a private investor with limited time and resources protect himself against this type of cataclysm?

The answer lies in the charts.

Every company has insiders who will always know more about what is really happening than you can. Those insiders will always trade on their superior knowledge before the facts are revealed to the public. Their trades will impact the share’s chart in specific ways which are clearly visible to the alert investor.

Let us consider the example of Steinhoff and what its chart revealed long before its ultimate collapse:

You can see here the meteoric rise of Steinhoff until March 2016 when its share reached a peak of 9685c. The share was a “market darling” and everyone was buying it – especially the big institutional investors.

Then something happened which should have alerted anyone who was watching the progress of Steinhoff’s upward trend. It made a “lower top” at 9479c on 7^th June 2016. The share went up and attempted to exceed its March 2016 high – and then failed. This failure was followed (as it usually is) by some disappointment and the share fell back to lower levels.

Then in August 2016, investors built up their courage to try again. But this time the share could only reach 9360c before it fell back. A second failure created a declining “triple top”. This is probably one of the most negative and bearish of all technical formations in charting. Anyone who was the least acquainted with the basic principles of charting would have been aware that Steinhoff was about to fall – and so it did.

But fund managers are stubbornly loyal to the idea that audited financials are reliable indicators of a company’s future performance. Indeed their entire training leads them to be so. But somebody inside Steinhoff already knew the truth and was busy off-loading a substantial portfolio of shares. Whenever the share reached high levels above 9000c that insider sold off another large chunk of shares – which were enthusiastically taken up – mostly by institutional investors.

There followed a period of about 15 months during which the share drifted down before the publication of the Viceroy report, the acknowledgement of “accounting irregularities”, and the resignation of Marcus Jooste as CEO brought the illusion to an abrupt end. The share collapsed from 5500c to less than 500c.

A person familiar with technical analysis will notice that after this third lower top, the share broke down through its long-term upward trendline – a clear sell signal. They would also have noticed that a massive long-term “head-and-shoulders” formation was becoming apparent.

This formation consists of a “right shoulder”, “head” and “left shoulder” and the low points which follow the right shoulder and the head can be connected to draw a “neckline”. Conventional technical wisdom is that a break below the neckline is the final signal of the coming bear trend. This break occurred on 10^th November 2017 – when Steinhoff was trading for 5600c. Shortly after that it collapsed by more than 90%.

You should take your time to study exactly what happened to Steinhoff and how you, as a private investor, could have avoided being a victim.  

DISCLAIMER

All information and data contained within the PDSnet Articles is for informational purposes only. PDSnet makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity, of any information, and shall not be liable for any errors, omissions, or any losses, injuries, or damages arising from its display or use. Information in the PDSnet Articles are based on the author’s opinion and experience and should not be considered professional financial investment advice. The ideas and strategies should never be used without first assessing your own personal and financial situation, or without consulting a financial professional. Thoughts and opinions will also change from time to time as more information is accumulated. PDSnet reserves the right to delete any comment or opinion for any reason.

PDSNET ARTICLES

Exponential Growth

The  S&P 500 index is important because all the stock markets around the world tend to follow it. If the S&P is in a bull trend then London, Tokyo and the JSE will also be in a bull trend – and vice versa.

The S&P500 index began 68 years ago on 4 th March 1957 with an initial value of 43,73. It took nearly

The US Jobs Market

International investors who trade on Wall Street are generally negative about any good news from the economy because it tends to make the monetary policy committee (MPC) more hawkish and less likely to reduce interest rates. The opposite is also true. But there comes a point where bad news is so bad that investors begin to fear that the US economy is heading

Jackson Hole

Once a year in late August central bankers and academics congregate in Jackson Hole to discuss the state of the economy and consider the way forward. Traditionally, the Chair of the Federal Reserve Bank (“the Fed”) addresses the meeting and gives direction to its thinking on monetary policy in the US. This year, the comments of Jerome Powell resulted in the

Choppies

Choppies is a supermarket chain which operates in Botswana, Namibia and Zambia. It is listed both on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) and on the Botswana Stock Exchange (BSE). Notably, the company has resisted the temptation to re-enter the highly competitive and cut-throat retail market in South Africa, having exited that market in 2020 due to sustained losses. Despite

Gold Resistance

All investments throughout the world can be ranked on a scale from high risk to low risk. As a general rule, in the world of investment, risk and return rise together. In other words, as the risks in an investment increase, so does the return necessary to attract investors.

At the one end of the scale there are very low risk investments

Sibanye takes off

We have been writing about Neal Froneman and Sibanye for years now. Beginning in 2013, Froneman assembled the Sibanye group over a period of 7 years, buying up mining operations both in South Africa and America at bargain prices. Initially he bought precious metals producers, but more recently he has been diversifying into base metals like zinc and lithium which

The 16 Year Bull Trend

Since the Second World War, the stock markets of the world, including the JSE, have always tended to follow the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) - and the NYSE is best measured by the S&P500 index (S&P) of its 500 largest companies.

For this reason, we believe it is important for private investors to constantly

CA Sales Revisited

Retailing in Africa is difficult with many of our leading retailers having attempted to open stores in countries to the North of us without notable success. These countries are often unstable and volatile politically. Getting adequate stock to branches has proved problematic and expensive.

It is not surprising therefore that a company has been

Bluetel

Bluetel (BLU) is a company involved in pinless top-ups, prepaid electricity, ticketing and universal vouchers. As such it is a company with substantial repeat business from existing customers. This type of business model is attractive to investors because it implies minimal working capital and strong cash flows.

Bluetel’s purchase

The Debtors' Book

A BIT OF HISTORY

Many years ago, in 1982 when I started this business (which became “PDSnet”), I ran advertisements in both the Rand Daily Mail (RDM) and in the Star – which were the two most widely read newspapers in Johannesburg at the time. At that time, we were a very small business and had no credit rating at all. Despite this the RDM immediately